Hobbit's being split in two.


Cygor - Posted on 17 December 2009

As you may or may not know a hobbit movie is currently in the works. And as you also may or may not know it's been planned as two movies from the start. But the twist here is that originally part one would contain the contents of the hobbit,while part two would contain events that occurred between the end of the hobbit and the start of lotr. WELL NOT ANYMORE!

Del toro seems to want to give more focus upon the relationship between Bilbo and the dwarves by stretching the book into two movies. While I wasn't really saddened by this news, I was surprised. It's been widely accepted by fans that the hobbit was too short to really constitute two full length movies. But I believe that is partiality due to people focusing on a few key events in the book and overlooking the journey itself.

There was a lot of in between in the book. The travel between the Shire and the last homely house, for instance could easily take thirty minutes. With the encounter of the trolls and locating the trail leading to the house itself. Stretching the plot of the book into two movies was probably the best possible way to stay true to the original content. And on a personal note; this movie needs Bearon in the worst way.

Joshura's picture

Interesting... I also heard that among the contenders for the role of Bilbo Baggins are Tobey Macguire and David Tennant.

I can't really imagine the story of the Hobbit separated, though, since there's really no resolution significant enough in the middle of the story to warrant a stop. It'll probably just end up feeling like Two Towers, where we were just left waiting for Return of the King.

Although, maybe if they were to end with Bilbo getting the ring... there'd be some place to go from there. Or maybe we can see Smaug, and subsequently the end of the dwarves' journey, then they stop, so the next movie is all about them defending their home and Smaug's defeat...? That almost seems like there's not enough plot.

Yeah, logically, it seems it would need to stop at Gollum. Word.

Chat plugin by BoWoB Chat for Drupal